Asian Film Foundation - 11/23/05 - Peter Chan Musical Perhaps Love

Hong Kong director Peter Ho-Sun Chan, working on his first musical film, Perhaps Love, said it was unlike any film he had directed before.

[Malay Times]
by Chow Ee-Tan

But putting aside the songs and dances, it was still a love story first and foremost to him.

And that?s what Chan is best known for, having directed such acclaimed films like Comrades, Almost A Love Story (1987) and She?s a Man, He?s a Woman (1994).

Chan, 43, got back to the director?s seat after directing Three, a collaboration with Korean and Thai film-makers three years ago (in between he financed and produced a number of movies), and before that forayed into Hollywood, directing The Love Letter for Dreamworks.

When he was approached to make a Chinese musical, Chan initially had his reservations.

"Although I enjoy musicals, I am not fanatic about it. Rather, I am a skeptic," he said in an interview in Kuala Lumpur recently.

"But it?s also because that I believe I can make some logic out of the genre for me and moviegoers. More and more people are watching movies at home on DVD and VCD. So I was thinking, what can I do to add to my kind of love story to get people to watch it on the big screen?" A musical love story was the answer.

Then he had to work out how to balance a reality-based emotional drama with flamboyant song and dance scenes.

"It was difficult as my kind of love story is neither sugar-coated nor dramatic. It is more on internal struggles."

It took Chan two years to write the script and six months to edit the final work.

Perhaps Love has been labelled the Chinese Moulin Rouge but Chan thinks it is just a ?convenient way to compare two movies?.

"When two movies are about the stage, obviously they have something in common but in terms of pacing, storyline and everything else, it is totally not Moulin Rouge."

Rather, Perhaps Love is about a director - Jacky Cheung, and two actors ? Takeshi Kaneshiro and Zhou Xun ? making a musical, and the only musical scenes take place in the musical within the film.

"People don?t break out into songs and dance, they sing only when the curtain rises. But it happens that the love triangle in the musical they play reflect the love triangle in their real lives.

"It is like a film within a film," he said. "The movie emphasises narrative and only 30 per cent of it is musical. It is not your typical musical."

He believes, however, the musical in the movie enabled the actors to express their feelings and emotions.

"The Chinese are quite introverted and they don?t communicate their internal feelings. These characters are able to vent out their emotions through lyrics and songs.??

Chan did not deny that stars like Kaneshiro and Cheung are crowd pullers but the fact that Perhaps Love is a musical has is own drawing power.

Famed Bollywood dance choreographer Farah Khan was roped in to choreograph the musical scenes.

"Most of the Hong Kong choreographers I know of are concert choreographers. I felt we should have one who understood the drama of a film, and I felt Bollywood musicals have the spontaneity, and the kind of energy that I want in the film.??

On his flight to Mumbai ? his first trip ever to India ? an Indian flight attendant recommended he had to get Farah Khan, saying she was ?the best?.

True enough, after meeting close to 10 choreographers, Chan decided only Farah fitted the bill as not only was she a brilliant choreographer, she could communicate what she wanted.

He said initially, he thought the most challenging aspect in filming would be the song and dance aspect.

"I was used to a more relaxed environment in my previous romance films. Now suddenly there were 300 people in the background, and some on wires. There were a lot of distractions so you have to really focus on the core story and the acting.??

But later, Chan said he realised post production and editing work were even tougher.

"I had to re-edit and re-edit and I?ve never edited so much for a film before. I had to draw a balance between a love drama and a musical extravaganza, the pacing and not let the musical scenes appear disjointed."

Chan is ever busier now. He has been having only four to five hours of sleep and have been flying to a different country every two to three days. Prior to Kuala Lumpur, he had travelled to Los Angeles, New York, Singapore and many cities in China.

On Dec 3, he would be back in Malaysia for a promotional tour with Kaneshiro, Zhou Xun and Ji Jin-Hee.

Chan said he would give romance films a break and will be working on a historical drama temporarily titled Assassination of Ma, which is about three friends at a time of strife and war in the Ching Dynasty.

"I?m also keen to do a realistic period drama and offer insights into the lives of the people then. All the period dramas that had been made were quite unrealistic and vague on the lifestyle then."

It is unlikely that he would direct another musical. "I?m not sure I can get it right the next time I do it. And I think my health can?t take it," he said.

So did he think he got it right this time? "I think so. I?ve done my best and now we just want people to come and watch it.

"However, everyone has their interpretation of a movie. There is no point for me to defend it," he said with a smile.

On a personal note, there had been reports that his long-term girlfriend, actress Sandra Ng is three-months pregnant but both Chan and Ng had never confirmed it.

However, when the question was raised after the press conference, a smiling Chan just said: "Why don?t you wait and see. These things can?t be concealed for long anyway."

Apparently, there were also reports that the couple had already quietly registered their marriage in Canada.

Source: http://www.mmail.com.my


asian.pop.culture.for.all